NewsWalt Disney World

Disney World Shut Down an Entire Island in 1999, and Guests Still Can’t Visit

Some of Walt Disney World's most beloved attractions have disappeared completely, leaving longtime fans with nothing but photographs and memories.

However, one former Disney attraction has a much stranger history.

Cinderella Castle at Magic Kingdom
Credit: Disney Fanatic

More than 27 years after closing, an entire island remains sitting in Bay Lake, surrounded by operating Disney resorts and busy transportation routes.

The property once welcomed thousands of visitors who traveled there to explore its wildlife exhibits and tropical surroundings. Today, nobody can legally visit without Disney's authorization.

And despite decades of speculation, the company has never announced plans to bring the attraction back.

The Island That Disney Guests Once Explored

Long before Disney's Animal Kingdom opened, Discovery Island served as one of Walt Disney World's most unusual destinations.

The 11.5-acre island originally opened as Treasure Island in April 1974, featuring pirate-themed elements inspired by Treasure Island (1950).

Disney later transformed the destination into a wildlife sanctuary, renaming it Discovery Island in 1977.

Guests traveled across Bay Lake by boat before exploring walking trails, bird exhibits, and animal habitats.

The island became home to exotic birds, giant tortoises, and other wildlife, offering an experience unlike the traditional attractions at Magic Kingdom.

As Disney Fanatic previously explained in its examination of Discovery Island's history and rumors, the attraction eventually developed a reputation that extended far beyond its wildlife exhibits.

However, its days as a public attraction were numbered.

A New Disney Theme Park Changed Everything

In April 1998, Disney opened Animal Kingdom, introducing an entire theme park dedicated to animals, conservation, and immersive environments.

The new park offered experiences that the smaller Discovery Island could not match.

Just one year later, on April 8, 1999, Disney closed the original island to visitors.

Its remaining animals were relocated, and the attraction's operations ended that summer.

disney world family (guests) in front of tree of life in animal kingdom
Credit: Disney

But unlike many former Disney World attractions that disappeared, Discovery Island wasn't demolished.

Instead, Disney left the property standing.

Over time, vegetation spread across the island, surrounding abandoned buildings, pathways, and former animal habitats.

Photographs from unauthorized explorers eventually revealed how dramatically the property had changed.

Disney Fanatic previously documented the island's history with urban explorers, although entering the property without permission remains prohibited.

Why Hasn't Disney Done Anything With It?

Discovery Island isn't the only abandoned Disney destination to attract attention.

Nearby River Country, Disney World's first water park, also sat unused for years after closing in 2001.

However, Disney eventually demolished that attraction to make room for future development.

guests at Disney's River Country water park
Credit: D23

The water park's unusual history is detailed in Disney Fanatic's look back at River Country's closure.

Discovery Island has followed a different path.

Although ideas for reusing the property have surfaced over the years, none has resulted in a public reopening.

Disney has continued removing and replacing older attractions elsewhere, including several discussed in Disney Fanatic's coverage of permanent attraction closures.

Yet the island remains untouched by any publicly announced redevelopment project.

A Forgotten Disney Attraction With No Reopening Date

Today, Discovery Island remains visible from certain areas around Bay Lake, but guests cannot explore its former attractions.

Its name lives on at Disney's Animal Kingdom, where Discovery Island surrounds the Tree of Life.

That location has experienced its own changes, including extended closures affecting the Discovery Island Trails.

Discovery Island Dock
Credit: Mark Walter/Flickr

However, the original island remains a separate, abandoned property.

As of November 2026, Disney has not announced a reopening date, replacement attraction, or confirmed redevelopment plans.

For fans who remember visiting Discovery Island, its continued existence offers a fascinating connection to Walt Disney World's past.

And for guests who never experienced it, the island remains one of the resort's greatest mysteries.

An entire Disney attraction closed more than a quarter-century ago, yet the land where it once operated is still there, waiting for a future that Disney has yet to reveal.

Brittni Ward

Brittni is a Disney and Universal fan; one of her favorite things at both parks is collecting popcorn buckets. While at Disney World Resort, Brittni meets the princesses and rides Kilimanjaro Safaris. At Universal, Brittni enjoys the Minions and watching Animal Actors on Location! When not at Disney World Resort or Universal Orlando, Brittni spends time with her family and pets.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles