A long-simmering Marvel “what if” has resurfaced, as a former Lost star confirms he once had a major X-Men role—only to see it slip away at the last minute.
Few films in Fox’s X-Men catalog inspire as much retrospective debate as X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009). Conceived as the first chapter in a series of origin-focused spinoffs, the movie promised to expand the mutant universe beyond team-based stories. Instead, it became a cautionary tale about overextension and creative gamble.
Released in 2009, the film marked Hugh Jackman’s first standalone Wolverine outing, surrounding him with characters intended to anchor future projects. Liev Schreiber appeared as Sabretooth, Ryan Reynolds debuted a heavily modified version of Deadpool, and several younger mutants were introduced as potential franchise-building blocks. While the ambition was evident, audience reaction quickly revealed cracks in the foundation.
X-Men Origins: Wolverine performed well financially, grossing around $373 million worldwide, but the critical reception was far less enthusiastic. Commentators highlighted inconsistent storytelling, abrupt tonal shifts, and creative decisions that failed to resonate, with Deadpool’s portrayal drawing particular scrutiny. Although Jackman’s dedication to Logan remained widely praised, the film ultimately slowed Fox’s push toward individual character spinoffs.
One of those stalled ideas involved Gambit. Portrayed briefly by Taylor Kitsch, the character’s appearance felt more like a placeholder than a proper debut, leaving fans curious about how close Gambit came to receiving a larger role in the franchise.
According to Josh Holloway, that role was once his. The actor, best known for playing Sawyer on Lost from 2004–2010, recently revealed that he had been cast as Gambit and even screen-tested opposite Jackman before the decision was reversed. Holloway shared the story during a recent convention appearance.
“Well, Gambit was one. As a matter of fact, I read with Hugh Jackman and got the part. They hugged me, said, ‘You're it! I'll see you on set,'” Holloway told Collider at Fan Expo Portland. “By the end of that evening, the studio head had called and said, ‘We want someone 10 years younger.' So they got Taylor Kitsch. Which, I wonder if he could come back? Who knows, but thank you. I learned the card tricks and everything.”
The recasting underscores how fluid Fox’s early X-Men plans were, particularly when it came to expanding the roster beyond Wolverine.
Gambit’s fortunes shifted again years later, when Channing Tatum became closely associated with the character. Tatum remained attached to a standalone Gambit film for nearly ten years as the project moved through multiple creative iterations.
The proposed movie was frequently described as a genre-blending take that emphasized personality and romance. Ultimately, the project was abandoned after Disney absorbed 20th Century Fox (now Studios), effectively ending the standalone film.
That wasn’t the end of Tatum’s involvement. In 2024, he finally appeared as Gambit in Shawn Levy’s Deadpool & Wolverine (2024). The film proved to be a box office hit and formally folded Gambit into Marvel’s broader Multiverse storytelling, exposing the character to a new generation of viewers.
Marvel Studios has since confirmed that Tatum will reprise the role in 2026's Avengers: Doomsday, positioning Gambit within one of Phase Six’s major ensemble events. The announcement marked a dramatic reversal for a character once seen as a casualty of studio reshuffling.
Beyond live action, Gambit has also regained visibility through X-Men ’97. The animated revival returned the character to the spotlight, though its success was tempered by controversy surrounding former showrunner Beau DeMayo, whose departure amid misconduct allegations created uncertainty about the show’s future direction. Even so, the series has kept Gambit firmly embedded in Marvel’s current lineup.
Gambit’s screen history reflects the broader turbulence of the X-Men franchise itself—shifting strategies, abandoned plans, and eventual reinvention. From Josh Holloway’s near-miss casting to Taylor Kitsch’s brief appearance and Channing Tatum’s long-awaited debut, the character’s journey has been unusually circuitous.
With Avengers: Doomsday on the way and animated stories continuing to expand, Gambit may finally be entering a more settled era. Whether this chapter delivers everything fans have hoped for remains an open question, but the character’s persistence alone has reshaped his place in Marvel history.
How do you feel about Josh Holloway's firing as Gambit in the Marvel movies? Let us know in the comments down below!
