Disney’s animated films of the 1990s remain iconic, with classics like Beauty and the Beast (1991), The Lion King (1994), and Aladdin (1992) capturing the hearts of audiences around the world. However, amidst these glittering successes stands a darker, more complex film—The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1996).
Based on Victor Hugo’s 1831 novel, The Hunchback of Notre Dame tells the story of Quasimodo, the bell-ringer of Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris. Raised by the villainous Judge Claude Frollo, Quasimodo is isolated from the outside world, convinced that his deformity makes him unworthy of love.
Related: The Most Underrated Disney Movies
However, that changes when he meets Esmeralda, a free-spirited Romani woman, who becomes the catalyst for Quasimodo’s transformation as he defies Frollo to help her escape persecution. With its mature themes of love, betrayal, and the struggle between good and evil, The Hunchback of Notre Dame stands out among Disney’s animated films for its darker content, which was often considered too intense for younger viewers.
While many Disney films include perilous moments, Hunchback delves deeper into darker themes—Frollo’s obsession with Esmeralda, the depiction of religious fanaticism, and the morally complex decision-making of the characters. This, coupled with memorable yet haunting songs like “Hellfire,” made the film a standout, though it didn’t quite match the commercial success of Disney’s other animated classics.
The Resurgence: A Certified Fresh Rating
Decades later, the film has gained a cult following, with fans increasingly appreciating its mature themes, breathtaking animation, and unforgettable score.
Just recently, The Hunchback of Notre Dame received a “Certified Fresh” rating on Rotten Tomatoes, an acknowledgment of its evolving legacy. Reviews from its original 1996 release were revisited, with the site aggregating 50 archival critiques to give it an 80% approval rating.
Critics like Roger Ebert described it as a “high point in the renaissance of Disney animation,” while Gene Siskel praised the film for its “effective songs” and “tasteful bits of humor.”
Michael Wilmington, writing for the Chicago Tribune, noted that while the film was “scary,” it was ultimately a powerful viewing experience for adults.
Except for Toy Story, Disney’s hasn’t really made a first-class scary movie — on the level of Dumbo, Bambi or Pinocchio — during its recent renaissance. The Hunchback of Notre Dame comes close, ringing the bells for adults if not their kids.
Related: This Is By Far the Most DISTURBING Song Disney Has Ever Created
The Live-Action Remake: Hopes and Roadblocks
In 2019, Disney announced plans to remake The Hunchback of Notre Dame as part of its ongoing effort to revamp its classic animated films into live-action spectacles. The project garnered significant excitement, especially with the return of Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz to create new renditions of the iconic songs.
Josh Gad, who had worked on Frozen (2013) and Beauty and the Beast (2017), was brought on as a producer, and there were even rumors that he might be considered for the role of Quasimodo himself.
For fans of the original, this sounded like a dream come true. The prospect of revisiting “Hellfire” and “Out There” in a live-action setting seemed tantalizing. However, despite the enthusiasm, the project soon began to face significant hurdles.
By 2023, the remake was officially canceled, and Alan Menken himself explained the challenges that led to the decision. The main sticking point? The film’s dark, mature themes simply didn’t fit well with today’s family-friendly expectations, especially for a live-action audience.
Menken explained that one of the central problems was the song “Hellfire,” sung by the villainous Judge Frollo. “You can’t have Hunchback without ‘Hellfire,’ but it’s just not something a lot of parents today would want their kids listening to,” Menken admitted.
Additionally, the film’s portrayal of Quasimodo’s deformity and Frollo’s obsessive behavior added another layer of complexity. The 1996 animated version, while powerful, dealt with these issues in a way that was palatable for its time but difficult to translate into a live-action film without raising concerns over its accessibility to a broad audience.
Even though the live-action remake has been shelved, The Hunchback of Notre Dame will undoubtedly continue to resonate with audiences for years to come. Whether revisited through its original animated form or through discussions of its cultural impact, the film’s themes of self-acceptance, moral struggle, and the power of compassion remain timeless.
What are your thoughts on the film’s cancellation and the challenges of adapting such a dark story for modern audiences? Let us know in the comments below!
