Fan Movement for Song of the South
Disney enthusiasts are reigniting their passion for Song of the South, particularly after the much-debated closure of Splash Mountain, a ride originally inspired by the film. This recent shift has spurred a grassroots movement to restore the film’s presence in the public sphere. Many fans are mobilizing to petition the National Film Registry, hoping to have Song of the South recognized and preserved for future generations.
This thread is about how to nominate the purged 1946 film Walt Disney's Song of the South to the National Film Registry. The deadline is Aug 15. The form is in the next comment. You need reasons why it should be on the Registry & this thread will give you several. pic.twitter.com/LLXBPqbWF4
— Ed McCray (@Real_Ed_McCray) May 25, 2025
Social media plays a crucial role in this resurgence. Platforms like Twitter and Facebook are abuzz with discussions and campaigns, creating a communal effort to contextualize and reevaluate the film’s historical significance at Disney. While some argue against returning the film due to its contentious narratives, others believe a nuanced approach is necessary. For these fans, Song of the South embodies a piece of Disney’s history that should not be quietly forgotten.
Historical Context of Song of the South
Released in 1946, Song of the South debuted during significant societal transitions following World War II. Disney sought to capture audiences’ attention by blending live-action with animation, based on stories from Joel Chandler Harris. Despite its problematic subject matter, the film garnered substantial box office success, earning over $65 million from multiple re-releases.
Critically, the reception was mixed. While the film won the Academy Award for Best Original Song for “Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah,” it also faced harsh criticism, particularly its blending of genres. The New York Times notably expressed disappointment, suggesting that this fusion caused Disney Animation to lose some of its magic. Nevertheless, the film’s musical contributions helped to solidify its place within the Disney canon.
Addressing Racial Concerns in the Film
From its inception, Song of the South has been criticized for perpetuating racial stereotypes, particularly through the character of Uncle Remus, played by James Baskett. Critics argue that the film’s portrayal of African Americans reflects a problematic narrative that emerged during a deeply segregated era.
Disney enlisted African-American writer Clarence Muse as a screenplay consultant to address these concerns. Unfortunately, Muse’s suggestions for a more dignified representation of African Americans were largely ignored, leading to his departure from the project. Baskett’s performance was celebrated, earning him a Special Academy Award; however, his legacy is forever intertwined with the historical inequalities of the Jim Crow era, casting a shadow over the film’s reception.
Disney’s Strategy for Obscuring the Film
In the decades following its release, Disney has systematically obscured Song of the South, choosing not to include it on platforms such as Disney+ or in significant media collections, including its 100th Anniversary box set. This absence seems driven by the company’s desire to distance itself from the film’s controversial themes and ensure its modern image remains intact.
While some fans express frustration at Disney’s efforts to suppress the film, others advocate for the importance of revisiting and understanding Song of the South. This ongoing divide signals an essential conversation regarding representation in media and Disney’s responsibility to confront its past. As supporters continue to rally for the film’s reexamination, the discussions surrounding it echo broader societal debates about race, history, and cultural accountability.
