4. Beaches and Cream (Beach Club Resort)
Overlooking Stormalong Bay, Beaches and Cream offers up burgers, sandwiches, and ice cream! While we have sampled the burgers and sandwiches, the true reason to head to this restaurant is to get some ice cream! Everyone should sample the Kitchen Sink since this is the most popular item on the menu. We love the intimacy of the restaurant – at maximum capacity, only about 50 people can be seated inside, so be sure to head here early or get an advanced dining reservation!