When Universal’s Wicked and Disney’s Moana 2 went head-to-head at the box office, it wasn’t merely a contest between two powerhouse studios—it was a cultural showdown that pitted a beloved Broadway musical phenomenon against a highly anticipated and controversial sequel. Both films have dominated the conversation in entertainment media, sparking passionate debates among fans and critics alike.
But beyond the headlines, who truly came out on top in this cinematic battle? Was it the magic of Wicked, with its long-standing legacy and fervent fanbase, or the continued charm of Moana 2, which faced its own set of challenges and expectations?
The Power of Wicked
From the moment Universal announced the film adaptation of Wicked, fans of the original Broadway sensation were abuzz with anticipation. Starring Ariana Grande as Galinda and Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba, the film dives into the untold story of the iconic witches of Oz. With its haunting melodies, intricate storyline, and themes of identity and acceptance, Wicked has been more than a musical—it’s a cultural touchstone.
For nearly two decades, Wicked has enchanted audiences on Broadway and beyond. Its songs like “Defying Gravity” and “For Good” have transcended the stage to become anthems of resilience and self-discovery. The film adaptation’s trailers and teasers only fueled this fervor, with fans dissecting every frame and eagerly awaiting the movie’s release.
Universal strategically shifted Wicked’s release date to November 22, just ahead of Disney’s Moana 2. This move paid off; the movie grossed over $450 million within weeks. Critics and audiences alike have celebrated Wicked for its breathtaking visuals, emotional depth, and standout performances. Ariana Grande’s transformation into Galinda and Cynthia Erivo’s powerhouse portrayal of Elphaba captivated viewers, making Wicked a certified crowd-pleaser.
More than just numbers, Wicked tapped into its loyal fanbase to create a cultural phenomenon. Social media erupted with reaction videos, fan art, and tributes, further solidifying its place as a beloved franchise. The movie’s 88% critics’ score and 95% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes underscore its widespread acclaim.
Related: Disabled ‘Wicked’ Actress Targeted by “Gross” Online Trolls
The Hurdles of Moana 2
Meanwhile, Disney’s Moana 2 faced a steeper climb. Originally conceived as a Disney+ series, the project was reimagined as a theatrical release after executives, including Bob Iger, were impressed by early footage. Positioned as the highly anticipated sequel to the 2016 blockbuster Moana, the film carried immense expectations.
Moana 2 opened on November 27, just five days after Wicked, and raked in over $680 million within three weeks. On paper, this financial success made it the clear winner. However, the sequel has struggled to replicate the magic of its predecessor. Critics gave Moana 2 a lukewarm 62% rating, while audiences offered a more generous 88% score.
Related: The First Reactions for ‘Moana 2’ Are Here (And It’s a Major Disappointment)
The criticisms have been sharp. Many viewers felt the movie’s narrative was disjointed, likely due to its origins as episodic content stitched together. The absence of Lin-Manuel Miranda, who wrote the music for the original Moana, was also glaring. The new soundtrack failed to deliver the same emotional resonance, leaving fans yearning for the unforgettable melodies of the first film.
Moreover, Moana 2 has been accused of playing it safe. While the original Moana broke ground with its focus on Polynesian culture and strong heroine, the sequel’s storyline has been criticized as formulaic and lacking the same depth. These shortcomings highlight the challenge Disney faces in balancing artistic integrity with the demands of a billion-dollar franchise.
Who Truly Won?
If the measure of success is box office revenue, Moana 2 edges out Wicked. But cultural impact tells a different story. While Disney’s sequel has enjoyed financial success, it has not resonated with audiences in the same way. The criticisms surrounding Moana 2 suggest a missed opportunity to elevate the narrative and honor the legacy of the original.
Wicked, on the other hand, has solidified its place in pop culture history. Its stellar reviews and emotional resonance have captivated audiences, ensuring its legacy will endure long after its theatrical run. The film’s success speaks to the power of storytelling and the importance of staying true to the heart of a beloved property.
In the end, Wicked and Moana 2 represent two sides of modern filmmaking: one rooted in passion and authenticity, the other driven by the weight of franchise expectations. For fans of both, the real winner might simply be the chance to experience these stories on the big screen—and to debate their merits long after the credits roll.
Have you seen Wicked and Moana 2 in theaters? Which one did you like best? Share your thoughts in the comments!
Moana 2 is the one with passion. WICKED is just by the numbers Hollywood fluff.