Disney Springs has become a hotspot not only for shopping and entertainment but also for some of the most sought-after dining experiences at Walt Disney World. Visitors frequently plan their trips around meals and snacks at unique locations, with one bakery in particular standing out for its indulgent offerings. Lines often form well before opening, as guests hope to get their hands on the bakery’s sweet creations.
Related: Here’s Why Gideon’s Bakehouse at Disney Springs Is Irresistible
Gideon’s Bakehouse has earned a devoted following since its soft opening in late 2020 and its official debut in January 2021. Known for its elaborate cookies and rich cakes, the bakery also releases monthly specialty items, keeping fans returning to see what new treats are available. The combination of classic favorites and rotating specials has made it one of Disney World’s most beloved dessert destinations.
Recently, the bakery faced an unexpected challenge. In a social media post, Gideon’s shared:
Rough news: We received some suspect cream cheese this week. It’s a bit off and consistency is of max important to us. So, as much as it may hurt, we’re dumping everything made from this week’s shipment, which includes Carrot Cake Slices for the Disney Springs location today and, unfortunately, this weekend’s release of Stuffed Guava Cream Cheese Sugar Cookies. It sucks. I apologize, but it’s the right thing to do. All should be back to normal next week.
Related: Gideon’s Bakehouse Virtual Queue Can Be Up To 4 Hours Long at Disney Springs
This temporary issue means that some fan-favorite items are currently unavailable, leaving a gap in the menu for eager visitors. However, Gideon’s made sure to soften the blow by introducing a unique alternative. In place of the missing Carrot Cake Slices, the team created a never-before-seen Chocolate Buttercream version of the “Steve Hates Sprinkles” Cake, featuring vanilla cake, rich chocolate buttercream, crunchy crumble, chocolate ganache, and a generous topping of sprinkles.
Despite the cream cheese setback, Gideon’s still offers plenty of treats for those visiting Disney Springs. Guests can enjoy the Chocolate Chip Cookie, Peanut Butter Crunch Cookie, Triple Chocolate Cookie, Gideon’s Bites, Dark Coffee Cake, Banana Bread Chocolate Chip Cookie, and double-frosted cakes.
Related: 10 Things to Do at Disney Springs That Guests Absolutely Love
Additionally, there are secret slices of cake that are released randomly, adding an element of surprise for dedicated fans.
The bakery also revealed a fun tip for visitors: a secret menu item.
“Did you know there is a secret menu item at Gideon’s in Disney Springs? You can ask to turn your Nitro Cold Brew into a float if you ask nicely. That’s right! The creaminess that a scoop of our Malted Vanilla Ice Cream, prepared by our local friends at @kellyshomemadeicecream is not just for Hot Cookie Hour. Enhancement Unlocked. There. You possess the knowledge. Do with it what you will.”
In addition to sweets, Gideon’s offers a variety of cold brew coffees to complement the desserts. Options include Original Peanut Butter Cold Brew, Classic White Cold Brew, French Toast Cold Brew, Cookie Butter Butterscotch Cold Brew, and a specialty Pumpkin Chai Cold Brew for the season.
While the cream cheese issue caused a temporary disruption, Gideon’s continues to provide a rich and satisfying experience for guests, maintaining its reputation for creativity and quality. The bakery’s transparency and playful approach to sharing news with fans have helped soften the impact, ensuring visitors still have plenty to enjoy.
Do you enjoy stopping by Gideon’s Bakehouse when visiting Disney Springs? What’s your favorite cookie or cake to try during your trip, and which cold brew do you pair it with? Share your experiences and favorite treats in the comments below!
