Walt Disney World Resort is known for its world-class attractions, magical entertainment, and a dazzling array of dining options. With over 200 restaurants across the parks and resorts, there’s something for everyone—but not every dining experience lives up to its hype. While some restaurants shine as guest favorites, others have left diners feeling underwhelmed.
In a lively discussion on Reddit, Disney enthusiasts shared the restaurants they found most disappointing—not necessarily because the food or service was terrible, but because the experience fell short of their high expectations. Here are the top five restaurants mentioned, along with the common criticisms shared by guests.
1. Space 220 (EPCOT)
The Hype:
Space 220 is one of the most immersive dining experiences at Disney World. Located in EPCOT, this restaurant transports guests 220 miles above Earth (or at least it feels that way). With a space station ambiance and stunning digital views of the galaxy, it’s designed to wow diners from the moment they enter.
The Letdown:
Many guests feel that Space 220 doesn’t deliver on its promise, especially considering the hefty price tag. While the concept is undeniably unique, some diners were unimpressed by the food quality and portion sizes. Reddit user u/Sinfulcinderella shared, “It was almost a year ago now, and we still talk about how bad it was.”
On the flip side, some families appreciated the immersive atmosphere, with one user noting, “The kids loved the experience, and we thought the food was good. It is a lot of money, but so is everything at Disney.”
Key Takeaway:
Space 220 is worth visiting if you’re excited about the space-themed ambiance. However, temper your expectations for the menu—and be prepared for a splurge.
2. Be Our Guest (Magic Kingdom)
The Hype:
Dining inside the Beast’s enchanted castle is a dream come true for many Disney fans. With stunningly themed rooms and the chance to experience scenes from Beauty and the Beast, Be Our Guest quickly became one of the most sought-after dining reservations at Magic Kingdom.
The Letdown:
While the ambiance is undeniably magical, the food has left some guests feeling cold—literally. A Reddit user remarked, “It was a cool experience walking in, but once seated… it just felt like any other large food hall with just okay, yet expensive, meals.” Others shared that the food arrived cold or was incorrectly prepared.
One commenter lamented the decline in quality over time, stating, “Be Our Guest is not what it once was.”
Key Takeaway:
Be Our Guest is a visual feast, but the dining experience may not justify the cost. Consider visiting for lunch instead of dinner to save money while still soaking in the atmosphere.
3. Beaches and Cream (Disney’s Beach Club Resort)
The Hype:
This retro-themed soda shop is famous for its over-the-top ice cream creations, including the iconic Kitchen Sink sundae. Located at Disney’s Beach Club Resort, it’s a nostalgic stop for ice cream lovers.
The Letdown:
Some guests feel that Beaches and Cream doesn’t live up to its legendary reputation. The OP of the Reddit discussion wrote, “The ice cream was great and all, but nothing else about that place inspired me to go back. One and done.”
Another guest noted that the restaurant lost some of its charm after a recent remodel, saying, “The remodel stripped its character away.”
Key Takeaway:
While Beaches and Cream is a must-try for ice cream aficionados, don’t expect a full dining experience to match its hype. Stick to dessert and soak in the retro vibe.
4. Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater Restaurant (Disney’s Hollywood Studios)
The Hype:
Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater offers a unique dining experience where guests sit in vintage car booths and watch campy 1950s sci-fi movie clips on a giant screen. It’s a nostalgic, quirky concept that promises a fun atmosphere.
The Letdown:
While many guests rave about the ambiance, the food often fails to impress. A Reddit user shared, “The atmosphere inside is great, but the food was just okay. The seating in the cars also isn’t what I remember it being.” Another commenter agreed, saying, “I love Sci-Fi because of the atmosphere, but the food is nothing special.”
Key Takeaway:
Visit Sci-Fi Dine-In Theater for the nostalgia and quirky decor, but don’t expect gourmet meals. It’s a great spot for a light bite or a novelty experience.
5. The Hollywood Brown Derby (Disney’s Hollywood Studios)
The Hype:
As a signature dining restaurant, The Hollywood Brown Derby offers upscale meals in a glamorous setting inspired by the golden age of Hollywood. It’s known for its famous Cobb salad and classic American cuisine.
The Letdown:
Despite its reputation, some guests have found The Hollywood Brown Derby to be underwhelming. One guest shared, “It was just an overall underwhelming experience, and thankfully the cast members working there did their best to make up for it.” Many noted that while the food and service are good, they didn’t feel the experience justified the cost.
Key Takeaway:
The Hollywood Brown Derby is best suited for guests seeking a quieter, more elegant dining experience. However, it may not deliver the wow factor for its high price point.
Final Thoughts
Dining at Walt Disney World is as much a part of the magic as the rides and shows, but not every restaurant can meet the high expectations set by Disney fans. While the above restaurants received mixed reviews, they all offer unique experiences that may appeal to different tastes and preferences.
If you’re planning a trip to Walt Disney World, remember that dining experiences are highly subjective. What feels disappointing to one guest might be another’s highlight. Do your research, read recent reviews, and consider trying these restaurants with an open mind.
What’s your most disappointing Disney dining experience—or your favorite hidden gem? Let us know in the comments below!
Most of these restaurants have a great vibe and a Disney feel. Unfortunately, Disney greed has done wonders, and not for the good, to food/menu quality. If not for the cast members, these restaurants would be total flops!