In an exclusive interview with PEOPLE, it was revealed that Jordan and Ellie had “exchanged custom vows outdoors at the stroke of midnight on the back courtyard of the Cinderella Castle before celebrating their new union with a pared-down reception”. Even though wedding receptions typically involve lots of eating and dancing, “the newlyweds simply shared a romantic first dance and cut into a multi-tier wedding cake before being whisked off in a vintage car down Main Street to Fisher’s song, “Happily Ever After,” which he recorded for the Magic Kingdom Park. That all sounds wonderfully magical to us, especially since Jordan and Ellie have a lifelong friendship that has made their romance that much stronger–and to top off the Disney princess romance of it all, Jordan reminisced about the event with just as much enthusiasm as if it had happened yesterday!